webecome Journal

7 October 2026 ยท S. Fatima, Advisor, WeBecome

Why telling everyone your plans can backfire, and who you should tell instead

Join WeBecome

Share your future. Find people going the same way.

Why telling everyone your plans can backfire, and who you should tell instead

Telling a big crowd about your plans can make you less likely to follow through, because being praised for the plan can feel like you already did it. But telling the right people, the ones you respect, and sharing real steps instead of big announcements, can help. Who you tell and what you share matter more than whether you share.

What did the research find?

Peter Gollwitzer and his team at New York University ran four studies. People who told others their plan to become something, like a lawyer, then worked less hard on it than people who kept it private. Being noticed for the plan gave them a sense of "I am already that person" (Gollwitzer and others, 2009). Psychologists call this "symbolic self-completion".

So should you keep your plans secret?

Not always. A study led by Howard Klein at Ohio State University found the opposite effect when people shared their plan with someone whose opinion they cared about, like a respected person. They became more committed and did better (Klein and others, 2020). The audience changes everything.

The difference: announcing and showing

  • Announcing is saying "I am going to run a marathon" to 500 people and getting praise now.
  • Showing is posting "Ran 3 km today, my knee hurt" to a few people who care and who are on a similar road.

Announcing gives you the reward before the work. Showing gives you support during the work.

Announcing and showing side by side

Announcing the planShowing the steps
Big crowdSmall, caring group
Praise for the ideaSupport for real steps
Feels done alreadyKeeps you moving
Hides setbacksSetbacks are shared too

Who should you tell?

  1. People you respect and who will notice if you stop.
  2. People on the same road, who understand the hard days.
  3. People who will ask "how is it going?", not just say "amazing".

How WeBecome helps

On WeBecome, progress only grows when you post a real step: an update, a photo, or a milestone. A setback adds nothing, but you can still share it. You choose who sees each future: Public, Circle or Private. People can say "Believe" to steps, not just to big announcements.

Questions and answers

Is it bad to tell people your plans? It can be, if you tell a big crowd and get praise too early. It helps if you tell people you respect and share real steps.

What is symbolic self-completion? It is when being noticed for wanting to be something makes you feel you already are. Gollwitzer's research showed it can reduce effort.

Who should I share my plans with? People you respect, people going through the same change, and people who will check in on you.

Should I share my setbacks? Yes, with the right people. It keeps the story honest and invites real support.

Should I post my plans on social media? Big announcements to many followers can backfire. Sharing steps with a small group usually works better.

Start your own future.

Share what you want, post small steps, and get support.

Join WeBecome

The Sunday letter

One calm read a week about who you are becoming.

No spam. Leave any time. See our Privacy notice.

Comments

What do you think? Share your own journey too.

Want to join the talk?